"He tried to make her understand. ‘This was an exceptional case. It wasn’t just a question of somebody being killed. Do you realize that the past, starting from yesterday, has been actually abolished? If it survives anywhere, it’s in a few solid objects with no words attached to them, like that lump of glass there. Already we know almost literally nothing about the Revolution and the years before the Revolution. Every record has been destroyed or falsified, every book has been rewritten, every picture has been repainted, every statue and street and building has been renamed, every date has been altered. And that process is continuing day by day and minute by minute. History has stopped. Nothing exists except an endless present in which the Party is always right." (128).
I feel that Winston is in somewhat of a unique position. These past few chapters have been good in displaying while how Winston cares for the future and the past of the Party for all, Julia only cares about those factors of the party which come in direct contact with her life. While Julia seems to grasp and contemplates some major hoaxes she believes the Party to be involved in i.e. the war, she is bored of the other lies the Party tells, accepting that things are just like that. I wonder how much of it is a generational difference. Julia doesn't remember a time before the Party at all while Winston does, Winston can vaguely remember that things might have been better before, but Julia holds no such memory.
Winston's overall understanding that to the Party only the present exists is quite interesting. The past is simply rewritten and falsified and there is no truth to any of it. The public has a complete lack of knowledge beyond the Party. They are being kept in the dark about everything slowly as time goes on the Party can claim to be responsible for more and more history. Winston notes that during his time in school the Party claimed to have invented helicopters, while in Julia's time they claimed to have also invented airplanes. The Party's ultimate goal it seems to be erasing more and more of the past until nothing remains but the Party. There will be no mention or fleeting memory of the time before the Party, only 'knowledge' that it was a horribly awful time and things are getting better. Old artifacts and trinkets will slowly disappear even in the proles housing, and the notice of anything but the present will be useless. No knowledge of history will be needed because it changes, no explanations of the changes will need to be made because not only will no one notice, but no one will care about the differences because the present is the only thing that carries weight.
The idea of 'history repeating itself' or 'learning from history' will be completely irrelevant as time marches forward because the history everyone learns will be the present. The only mistakes that will be learned from are the 'capitalist in top hats' and even then history is dictated by what the government wants you to see. History as always will be dictated by the winners and the Party is always right, so the Party will always win. With the severe restriction on history, the restraint of public knowledge, and the shunning of individualism, it doesn't seem like Winston's time is far off from what the Party truly wants: a nation of 'good' people afraid stir the pot or ask any questions about the way things are.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
My Final Blog, Finally
So I'm finally writing my last blog, apologies Mr. Ross for my blogs being varying degrees of late, but to make up for it I hope, this o...
-
So I'm finally writing my last blog, apologies Mr. Ross for my blogs being varying degrees of late, but to make up for it I hope, this o...
-
"In principle, a Party member had no spare time and was never alone except in bed. It was assumed that when he was not working, eating,...
-
"Science, in the old sense, has almost ceased to exist. In Newspeak there is no word for ‘Science’. The empirical method of thought, on...
I honestly agree with what you have to say because as I was reading I was having some of the same thoughts. We can see as we read chapters 3-6 that Winston tries to get her to understand the importance of what he is saying but she acts like she couldn't care less about what he was saying because she saw it as 'irrelevant' because it was just how things were. I think you are very right on the generational gap because like those kids that are completely brainwashed into basically worshiping the Party, she is also in the situation because she cannot remember a time before the Party so she really has nothing to compare the times to and it makes her accept it 'as the way things are'. So I can see how you drew your conclusion about how the Party is getting close to what they want. You did such a great job on pulling everything in together and putting your ideas so clearly so people can follow along very easily. You did such a great job on your post!!
ReplyDeleteI think the generational gap between Winston and Julia could be a good argument for why there ways of thinking are different. Even today, the older generation will complain about how times were simpler "back in their day" and how today's kids don't appreciate what they have. Winston knows that there was a time that was better and wants people to desire that type of life back when he was younger, but the younger generation doesn't really have a drive to follow that.
ReplyDelete